Ubik wrote:Day 1 is tough though and I naturally tend to suspect those that are less active, which isn't ideal.
So of the less active, who would you consider voting for?
Micky wrote:Inconq, already voting for me?! I don’t know if I feel honored or upset. But because I love you, I’ll be okay with it.
I love you too! This response is... really tame for you? I have to be honest I was expecting you to be a bit more taken aback like you were in previous games, but this is almost dismissive. I didn't think I was going to do this, but I'm leaving my vote on Micky for now.
---------------------------------
Ok so my question from the beginning of the game. My answer to it: mass role-claim would be a horrible idea. Following my trying to find townies strategy, I wanted to see what people would say to the idea. I didn't expect mafia to come out and be all for it, but I thought that I could find some hints based on the answers. This is what I found (in order from the player list on the first page):
Lotha: Gave a solid answer, basically agreeing that it would be a bad idea.
Ubik: I liked his answer too. About half the group had answered by this point but he added a new element to his answer unique from everybody else. I like the unique thinking.
Andy92: Kind of just openly mocked the question.
Micky: Didn't answer.
Silver: Hers was the last answer (which is fine), she didn't have anything new to add but agreed that it would be bad. Neutral feelings on this.
Timotheus: Gave a good answer that I liked right away.
Cam: Solid answer, again agreeing that it's a bad idea.
Summer: Gave me the best answer, the one that aligned with my view the most. This is why I have her in my town group right now. She thought it would be bad and was unabashed about it.
So from the question I got my three town vibes that I mentioned on the last page, and they have basically stayed since then. Lotha and Summer have become more solid town reads since. Micky just not answering is probably ok, he didn't really answer much when he came into the thread (except my vote and his birthday), but his subdued reaction to my vote puts him as the most suspicious for me right now. It's day one so this isn't a great case, but it's what I have right now.
I want to give Andy the benefit of the doubt here. He hasn't given us really... anything yet, but he can't
always be mafia. Am I giving him a pass? No. But right now I don't think I'm willing to vote there today. Also won't be voting for Lotha or Summer.