This is probably one of, if not the, weakest battle for me. Apart from Metalingus and Poison, all of these tracks are among the weakest off their individual albums, though Poison is only an exception because TLH has a lot of "weak" tracks for me (My Champion, YWBR, Losing Patience, Crows, TWOTW). Metalingus, while it's definitely not in my top 20, has a special place in my heart because, as so many others, I've come to known Alter Bridge by listening to Edge's WWE theme, so that's a very, very clear victory.
By the way, even though Poison is kind of an exception from what I've written above, it's still not the second-best track in this battle in my books. Still Remains just happens to be on the best album AB have ever put out. So:
Poison In Your Veins
The Uninvited/Native Son