zazthespaz wrote:Good morning! Should be a little more active today! So based on my skimming over the past couple of pages, it seems that we have 2 role claims. I think it’d be important for others to counter claim those roles if they are in fact those roles. There are a lot of arguments I need to re-read, but if nobody counter claims a role, I might side with either Micky or Summer on their vote since they’re likely to be townies and it makes sense to side with them. (Again, need to re-read a lot so if I see an argument that makes sense or gives decent info, I might come up with a new theory. Essentially, this post is to say I’m here and will be more active today so don’t write me off yet please!)
Yeah I think you're safe for today just by virtue of Ubik's Nale findings on Micky, but you're in the process of elimination for me basically because almost everybody else has bumped themselves above your position today. Looking forward to seeing your contributions.
Timotheus wrote:3. Ubik: he's gone up on my list, because zaz has been very quiet. The suspicion is still kind of there. I find it kind of suspicious that the guy he proposes to lynch is the guy I put on the bottom of my previous list, but that's mostly me having trust issues. We seem to be agreeing a lot, so I feel a bit more confident about him. Or at least about working together with him.
So obviously things have changed, my thought at the start of the day was that his question on a surface level seemed ripe for misinformation type answers, but that he was also looking for somebody to search in the night. Everything else I've seen from him has me trusting him a lot.
Timotheus wrote:4. The Dissident: Love how he's like: "didn't read last page, but I received an offer last night". This also wasn't his first post on day two. As long as there's no counter-claim, I feel like we have to trust him. The idea that the mafia didn't offer anybody an offer on day one, is hard for me to believe. They've got to take every chance they have because if Odium gets killed or lynched it's not -1 but possibly -2 mafias.
I agree that mafia should always at least take the chance. Like Lotha has said, he's a good candidate for it too since he's a quiet player as either alignment. I think I mentioned that mafia might not have sent an offer out, or at least came up with an explanation for why. I don't buy into it at all, but if nobody had claimed that they had gotten an offer, the possibility that they just didn't to get us to go around in circles all day is... plausible (at best). Anyway, I believe him for now based on his posts between the two days.
Timothus wrote:8. Silver: Last game she was mafia, and I don't remember her making lists like the did on page 10. For the rest she hasn't posted a lot, so there's just not that much information, to start trusting her. I put her before Micky, because I feel like she's been a lot more transparent. Putting Lotha at the bottom was pretty ballsy.
I agree, I do have her a bit higher right now after her reads post. I thought most of it was really well thought out and it came from a solid town perspective. I see your reasoning here though.
zazisaspaz wrote:@Timo, I don’t want sympathy, I just think it’s annoying how people can be like “oh my gosh she’s acting so weird for saying she doesn’t have any good reads on anyone” which is literally the whole point of the game. And to that point, if people do vote me off, I don’t want them to feel bad about it. Haha it’s definitely more sympathy for others than myself the way I see it.
Also, Cameron said he wanted to look more into one of my reasons for voting for you... how on earth is that him agreeing with me or jumping on a bandwagon? Now I’m kinda wondering if I rescinded my vote for you too soon...
Well... the point of the game is to get reads on people. I'm super wary of you, but this post...
zazisaspaz wrote: Lotha wrote:
Shallan should definitely counter-claim. As you said, it's not really a vital role, and it doesn't really out the doctor - still a lot of potential targets for that. Ubik, I don't like your thought process here
I agree it’s not necessarily the most vital, but it could protect the cop or the doctor from being discovered by mafia. Just in case anyone else was confused by this role, I figured I would share that tidbit
...feels super townie to me. I wish I had a conclusion on your role, but based on the events of the day, you'll be around for us to look into further, which is... something at least.
Ubik wrote:Honestly? Had a feeling it would come up town and that the mafia would try to push on him as a miss-kill today. I'm also aware of the fact that sometimes his busy-ness can work against him with how he's perceived, and wanted something solid on him.
Smart. I like it!
Going to end this post off with a reads list as well. I think Ubik's plan regarding Summer should clear her as well... but until then I'm very tentative. If anybody wants me to expand on anything, please let me know.