Mafia: The Witcher: The Hunt for Ciri [Game Over! Page 6]

[Ubik]

Changing my outlook on Timo to "questionable".

[zazisaspaz]

Lol @ Summer being Yennefer.

Right?!? Hahaha what are the chances

What kind of a cold hearted person would vote me off the first day?! Is this what I get for inviting someone to join the game? Sheesh! Lololz kidding, this is a solid bunch of super friendly people playing so I’m just glad I didn’t have to choose. I look forward to lurking on the rest of this game!

[Inconquerable]

Move in with me and i'll make sure you never get compared to Shea again

Is your dog a cuddler? If so I'm in!

I think a logical mafia player would play the "no vote" card as early as possible, which is why I'm kinda suspicious about Incon and Ubik.

Fair, I was thinking the same about you though since you jumped on my thought quicker than anybody. I figured it was either a good town move, or a sneaky mafia tactic.

[SHEAKENBAKEN]

Move in with me and i'll make sure you never get compared to Shea again

Is your dog a cuddler? If so I'm in!

Move in with me so I don't have to move with my parents and we'll get our own dogs!!

[Andy92]

My infatuation with Yen makes so much sense now.

[AB4Lyfe]

Who benefits the most from killing Summer? Based on the first day, nobody. It's either a random kill based on nothing or a very cleverly chosen kill, designed to not step on anybody's toes.

I think a logical mafia player would play the "no vote" card as early as possible, which is why I'm kinda suspicious about Incon and Ubik.
AB4lyfe was early as well, but when I was mafia with him he was rather reluctant to vote in public this early.

You ever play the game Mindnight? Little known game on Steam, but similar premise in that it’s a social deduction game. I was always reluctant to vote anything crazy in that game for the first round as well because we don’t have any info; running in blind. So I usually play it slow no matter what role I’m in.

But, that being said, Andy had an awesome guess on Butters last game, that was entertaining

[Timotheus]

Changing my outlook on Timo to "questionable".

I'm not pointing any fingers, just reasoning out loud. Like Incon said, voting early for nobody could be a good town move, or a sneaky mafia tactic. Same thing with Summer's death. Could be tactical, could be random.

It's often the way people act and react that's more revealing. Inconquerable reacted calmly and rationally to her name being dropped. Ubik got a little defensive.

You ever play the game Mindnight? Little known game on Steam, but similar premise in that it’s a social deduction game. I was always reluctant to vote anything crazy in that game for the first round as well because we don’t have any info; running in blind. So I usually play it slow no matter what role I’m in.

For the record, I was speaking in favor of you not being mafia

[Ubik]

Changing my outlook on Timo to "questionable".

I'm not pointing any fingers, just reasoning out loud. Like Incon said, voting early for nobody could be a good town move, or a sneaky mafia tactic. Same thing with Summer's death. Could be tactical, could be random.

It's often the way people act and react that's more revealing. Inconquerable reacted calmly and rationally to her name being dropped. Ubik got a little defensive.

You ever play the game Mindnight? Little known game on Steam, but similar premise in that it’s a social deduction game. I was always reluctant to vote anything crazy in that game for the first round as well because we don’t have any info; running in blind. So I usually play it slow no matter what role I’m in.

For the record, I was speaking in favor of you not being mafia

I was semi kidding, I just found it curious that you were judging my actions in a way that would also throw suspicion on yourself using the same logic. And given no-one else is really giving anything there's not much to go on. But I maintain what I said in my last post - in this game it seems paramount to reduce the chances of Ciri getting killed, so I'm still less inclined to believe you're mafia.

[Micky]

is your dog a cuddler? If so I’m in!

He is, he even lets you use him as a pillow.

[AB4Lyfe]

Changing my outlook on Timo to "questionable".

I'm not pointing any fingers, just reasoning out loud. Like Incon said, voting early for nobody could be a good town move, or a sneaky mafia tactic. Same thing with Summer's death. Could be tactical, could be random.

It's often the way people act and react that's more revealing. Inconquerable reacted calmly and rationally to her name being dropped. Ubik got a little defensive.

You ever play the game Mindnight? Little known game on Steam, but similar premise in that it’s a social deduction game. I was always reluctant to vote anything crazy in that game for the first round as well because we don’t have any info; running in blind. So I usually play it slow no matter what role I’m in.

For the record, I was speaking in favor of you not being mafia

I know I wasn’t trying to insinuate you were accusing me, just explaining I start slow no matter what because to me that’s the logical thing to do.

[Inconquerable]

He is, he even lets you use him as a pillow.

That's adorable!!

So I usually play it slow no matter what role I’m in.

I think I agree with this. Duane is sometimes a hard read for me because he does play the same way almost every time we've played (that I can remember anyway).

Shea you haven't posted anything game-related in day two, any thoughts? Just trying to see if I can get some answers here. Some random thoughts:

Not sure how I feel about Ubik right now. He seems different than the last game to me still.
Andy hasn't said much game-related either, auto-suspicion for him because of his history is alive though. =P
Micky might be a little shady too, please don't revoke my dog cuddling privileges!!

This is just based on small things from the last two pages, not a tonne to go on but this is where my brain is right now.

[Andy92]

I think you’re all pretty shady right now but that might be my Coronavirus anxiety acting up.

[zazisaspaz]

My infatuation with Yen makes so much sense now.

[Inconquerable]

In light of the lack of information we have right now, I think we need to look further into Summer being killed off first. I was a little surprised by it because I was suspicious of her early on (sorry!!), I didn't think she would be voted out first based on that because I probably would have questioned her today if she had made it through the night. I'm glad I didn't have to though because it wouldn't have gotten us anywhere good, but now I'm trying to piece together A) who did it, and B) why they picked her.

Suspects are still the same for me as in my last post, with Timo kind of floating around the middle of the pack for me. Anybody have anything we can go on?

[Andy92]

I’m pretty stumped honestly. Seems like a randomized target, which after a day phase of no votes, I guess about any target from the mafia would be random on the first night.

After reading back through the thread, the only thing that’s a little odd is Shea’s quick vote for Incon lol. It seems like it was done in jest, but it’s tough to find much of a lead otherwise.

[Ubik]

If we can't figure out the mafia angle yet, how about we try and help the town another way - Triss and Geralt need to get together (sorry Yen) to share what they know. This may conceivably have already happened if Triss got lucky investigating last night, but it seems unlikely given there was a 1 in 7 chance. Are there any shenanigans we can pull to make them connecting any easier, without the mafia finding out who's who? Or is it just a matter of hoping for luck?

[Micky]

I wish I understood any of the Witcher

[SHEAKENBAKEN]

VOTE: INCONQUERABLE

[Ubik]

VOTE: INCONQUERABLE

That's the second vote you've put in for her. Got a lead?

[SHEAKENBAKEN]

VOTE: INCONQUERABLE

That's the second vote you've put in for her. Got a lead?

My lead is my vote.